‹ Cards
53 of 259

Riddles in the Dark HOB 0053 · rare

Riddles in the Dark · {2}{U} · Instant · Look at the top four cards of your library and separate them into a face-down pile and a face-up pile. An opponent chooses one of the piles. Put that pile into your hand and the other into your graveyard. · "What have I got in my pocket?"
—Bilbo

Riddles in the Dark · {2}{U} · Instant · Look at the top four cards of your library and separate them into a face-down pile and a face-up pile. An opponent chooses one of the piles. Put that pile into your hand and the other into your graveyard. · "What have I got in my pocket?" —Bilbo

Price
from $0.232 printings
Win rate
53.1% GIH 1,502 instances · Pick-Two Draft
Aug 11–Sep 22, 2026 · 17Lands

Game-in-hand win rate, all deck colors. 797 wins in 1,502 card-in-hand instances.

1,471 distinct games · 794 distinct drafts · games recorded Aug 11–Sep 22, 2026.

17Lands file dated Oct 1, 2026 · 100-instance minimum · 17Lands public data ↗ (opens in a new tab)

Draft data

53.1%when drawn (GIH)

−3.3 pp vs 56.3% average · 1,502 instances

Pick-Two Draft · Aug 11–Sep 22, 2026 · average from 171,956 games

#136 of 179 nonland cards by win rate · last seen around pick 2.9 on average (9,044 packs).

20 of 27 blue cards · 4 of 7 blue rare cards.

Taken at pick3.62,936 picks
Makes the deck38.5%1,617 picks with known usage
When played51.4%2,054.2 matchesBenched 55.5%
3,292.8 matches
When drawn53.1%1,502 instances

Pick and maindeck observations: Aug 11–Sep 22, 2026. Played/benched cells use matches when available; the drawn cell uses game instances.

○ Opening hand 55.2% · 554 instances
● Drawn later 51.8% · 948 instances

In hand 53.1% · 1,502 instances
Unseen in deck 49.3% · 1,783 instances
+3.8 percentage points when drawn

Compared with blue cards

Win rate when drawn53.1%1,502 instances20 of 27
Opening hand55.2%554 instances8 of 26
Drawn later51.8%948 instances23 of 27
In the deck51.0%3,284 instances19 of 27
Without seeing it49.3%1,783 instances22 of 27
Improvement when drawn+3.8 pp1,502 instances / 1,783 instances14 of 27
When benched55.5%3,292.8 matches13 of 28
Makes the deck38.5%1,617 picks with known usage17 of 28
Pick (last seen)2.99,044 packs7 of 28
Taken at3.62,936 picks8 of 28

Ranks require 100 observations for that metric; comparisons are descriptive, not a pick order. Pick ranks put earlier picks first.

Best decks for it

no-splash decks only · card-level in-hand rates · 100 minimum

Lake-town WU53.7%614 instancesElvenking’s Halls UG50.7% ◌223 instancesBlue–Red UR55.9%34 instances · under 100Blue–Black UB52.9%85 instances · under 100

Each tick is this card’s all-decks rate (53.1% · 1,502 instances). A high card rate does not prove that splashing it will improve your deck.

Usually played with

Deck co-occurrence; not evidence of synergy.

Bilbo Baggins, Burglar2,152 games with both in the deckEnchanted River's Grasp1,928 games with both in the deckLakeshore Apothecary1,881 games with both in the deck
How to read this

Observational, not a causal bonus. Both cards must be in the deck. Drawn means opening hand or normally drawn; each card counts once per game. Game-level approximate intervals do not account for repeated games by the same drafter.

At least 100 games in each of four drawn/not-drawn groups; adjusted for game length and screened by the lower confidence bound. Do not add these points to a card’s win rate.

Where it sits in the set

Above 24% of 179 nonland cards with 100+ instances, in win-rate order.

30% or lowerWin rate94% or higher

17Lands public datasets ↗ (opens in a new tab) · CC BY 4.0 ↗ (opens in a new tab) · Aug 11–Sep 22, 2026

Collect

2 printingsTCGplayer market price · Nov 8, 2026Pack odds →

Pick a printing for its prices and pull odds.

Prices

HOB 0053 · Main setListings ↗ (opens in a new tab)
FinishFound inPrice
NonfoilPlay Booster$0.23TCGplayer market price · Nov 8, 2026
FoilPlay Booster · Collector Booster · prerelease$0.32TCGplayer market price · Nov 8, 2026

Foil in a Play Booster · Modeled · About 1 in 700 packs (0.14%) · 4.2% per display · MTGJSON model Nov 9, 2026 · How it’s modeled →

Nonfoil in a Play Booster · Modeled · About 1 in 50 packs (1.99%) · 45.3% per display · MTGJSON model Nov 9, 2026 · How it’s modeled →

Foil in a Collector Booster · Modeled · About 1 in 30 packs (3.30%) · 33.2% per display · MTGJSON model Nov 9, 2026 · How it’s modeled →

Foil in a prerelease · Modeled · About 1 in 61 packs (1.65%) · MTGJSON model Nov 9, 2026 · How it’s modeled →

How to pull it

Official rates for the whole category, not this card.

BoosterSlotPer packCategory
Play BoosterNonfoil wildcard17.3%Main set · rare
Play BoosterNonfoil rare or mythic82.9%Main set · rare
Play BoosterFoil wildcard7.1%Main set · rare
Collector BoosterFoil main-set rare or mythic87.6% per positionMain set · rare

Wizards: Collecting The Hobbit ↗ (opens in a new tab) · Jul 18, 2026

Details & sources

Legal in
Standard · Historic · Timeless · Pioneer · Modern · Legacy · Vintage · CommanderLimited eligibility depends on the event and its booster pool.
Illustration
Lorenzo Mastroianni, HOB 53 · Scryfall ↗ (opens in a new tab)
More like this
rare cards →
Sources
Wizards: Collecting The Hobbit (opens in a new tab) · Jul 18, 2026
TCGplayer market price · Nov 8, 2026
Comprehensive Rules ↗ (opens in a new tab)